Milburn's £5.8bn-a-Year Youth Jobs Plan Bets £500m Now for £13.8bn Later
Milburn's youth jobs plan needs £500m upfront and £5.8bn a year by 2036-37, promising £13.8bn in welfare savings over a decade. Small firms get £5,000 per Neet hired.
By Nathan Brooks
4 min read

What's News
- Milburn's plan requires £5.8bn a year of funding by 2036-37, offset by £3.6bn welfare savings and £2.4bn extra tax revenue
- An immediate upfront payment of £500m is required in the next financial year; overall savings overtake costs only after 10 years
- Small businesses would get £5,000 for hiring a young Neet, with the plan projecting £13.8bn in welfare savings over the decade
- UK unemployment unexpectedly eased to 4.6% as the report published
- Milburn reported an 'incredibly positive' response from Labour MPs, contrasting with last year's disability benefits rebellion
Alan Milburn's youth unemployment report proposes £5.8bn a year of spending by 2036-37, offset by £3.6bn of welfare savings and £2.4bn of extra tax revenue from people in work. The former health secretary's plan, titled From a Welfare State to a Working State, publishes this morning — and it starts with an immediate upfront payment of £500m in the next financial year.
The hard arithmetic: the plan costs before it saves. Asked directly whether it "costs, doesn't save" in the short term, Milburn told the Today programme: "Correct." The crossover point — when overall savings overtake costs — arrives only after the full 10-year programme runs its course, a timeline Milburn confirmed with "That's when it happens." By then, he says, the government will have saved about £13.8bn from the welfare budget.
What does this change for employers and young people?
The most concrete sweetener: small businesses would receive a £5,000 payment for hiring a young person classified as Neet — not in education, employment or training. Milburn told Sky News the payment would "help you absorb the costs of their hiring." Incentives on the table also include cuts to employers' national insurance contributions for workers aged 21-24 in retail and hospitality; ordinary earners under 21 are already NI-free.
Delivery runs through youth hubs — what Milburn calls welcoming places, "not jobcentres where they're met by security guards, but places only for young people." Last week he visited a model hub at Merseyside Youth Association in Liverpool. Hiring and training a new cohort of work coaches and advisers has begun, so hubs can offer supported internships, short flexi-jobs and experience for those with empty CVs.
Local mayors — or councils where mayors don't exist — carry the colossal task of pulling schools, FE colleges, jobcentres, NHS services and local employers out of their silos. Extra funding comes with accountability for delivering a continuous decline in local Neet numbers.
Why Labour MPs are signalling support this time
When Keir Starmer's government proposed cutting disability benefits last year, a huge backbench rebellion forced it to back down. As the Guardian's Pippa Crerar explains, Milburn learned from that debacle. He spent months making a moral argument — unlike Starmer and Rachel Reeves, who justified cuts principally on cost grounds.
Milburn said his meeting with Labour MPs drew an "incredibly positive" response because they recognised a "moral imperative" to act, alongside the economic case. Labour MPs "have to vote for it," he said. "Labour is what it says on the tin. It's the party of work. It's not the party of welfare and of benefits."
He conceded the trade-off plainly: "There will be some young people who are worse off at least initially as a consequence of benefit changes. But in the end, the best thing for people is to get them into work." He argued that too many young people enter the welfare system who "frankly shouldn't be there," and that anxiety, depression or moderate ADHD shouldn't prompt the question "What can't you do?" — but rather "What could you do? What could we help you do?"
The fiscal pledge — and the timing
Milburn told Times Radio the government could start saving money from the welfare budget before the end of this parliament. That matters politically: John Healey, the chancellor, was criticised by the Tories recently for failing to propose benefit cuts before the next election.
Milburn's counter to crude cuts: "all that then happens is more young people are in destitution and poverty and frankly will show up somewhere else on the ledger in more housing costs or health costs or crime costs. Or we can do it through more jobs."
Politics today: the report's first real test
The UK unemployment rate has unexpectedly fallen to 4.6% as the report lands. Andy Burnham chairs cabinet at 9.30am, where Milburn will speak. Milburn holds his press conference at 11.30am, and work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden gives a Commons statement after 12.30pm. The DWP publishes quarterly universal credit figures at 9.30am; Downing Street briefs at noon.
Reaction from the charity sector hasn't been hostile, and opposition parties have welcomed the parts overlapping their own policies. Polly Toynbee's verdict in the Guardian column frames the stakes: if even half these plans work, it would mark "a generational shift from appeasing the old to finally directing hope and resources towards the young." Milburn stays in post to oversee implementation — so the 10-year clock, and the £13.8bn promise, now start running against him.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,249 articles