QQQ's Second 200-Day Break in 7 Days: History Says Mostly Noise
QQQ broke its 200-day twice in 7 days. Of 35 prior cases since 1999, 66% recovered within 5 sessions — but three became bear markets with 28-48% further losses.
By Nathan Brooks
3 min read

What's News
- QQQ closed below its 200-day on Nov 5 (647.05) and again Nov 13 (679.89), now ~3.8% under the line (~682.6).
- Since 1999, QQQ had 35 cases of a repeat break within 7 sessions; 66% recovered within 5 sessions.
- Three cases (Jan 2002, Aug 2008, Apr 2022) stayed below 60+ sessions and fell 48%, 45% and 28% further.
- VIX sits at 25.46 vs a ~19.99 trigger; the Risk-Off Ladder holds 0% exposure at 2 of 3 warnings.
- SPY closed Tuesday at 732.44, barely above its 200-day (~732.3); a close under ~732.6 triggers its second warning.
QQQ closed below its 200-day moving average twice in seven sessions — Nov 5 at 647.05, briefly back above on Nov 11, then under again on Nov 13 at 679.89 — and history says a break that fast is usually noise, not a death sentence.
That's the core finding from TradingView analyst TheSimplePortfolio, who checked every prior instance of the pattern. Since 1999, QQQ has seen 35 cases where a close below the 200-day came within seven sessions of the last one. The record is more reassuring than this week's tape feels.
What did the last 35 double breaks do?
The numbers cut both ways, and practitioners should see both sides:
- Median time below the line: 3 sessions. 23 of 35 cases (66%) were back above within 5 sessions.
- 3 of 35 stayed below more than 60 sessions: January 2002, August 2008, April 2022. Those three fell another 48%, 45% and 28% from the break close.
- 20 sessions later, QQQ was higher in 18 of 35 cases (median +1.7%). At 60 sessions out, higher in 21 of 35 (median +2.0%).
"So a repeat break is mostly noise, close to a coin flip a month out, but every one of the big bear markets also started with breaks like this," the analyst wrote. "That's why I don't act on the 200-day alone."
That's the practical tension. The base rate favors mean reversion — roughly a coin flip with a slightly positive median return a month out — but the tail risk is severe. Half of the three disasters lost 45% or more.
Where the tape stands now
QQQ kept sliding after the second break: 661.75 on Monday, 656.95 on Tuesday, a 0.7% drop that left it about 3.8% under the 200-day, which sits near 682.6. Nvidia then reported a clear beat after Tuesday's close and Nasdaq futures rose overnight.
The author's response to that: don't cheer yet. "A great earnings print isn't an all-clear. The rule doesn't read headlines or futures; it waits for a close."
What does this change for risk models?
TheSimplePortfolio runs three free tools, and here's where each stood at Tuesday's close:
- Risk-Off Ladder: 2 of 3 warnings active — VIX at 25.46, well above its ~19.99 trigger, plus QQQ under the 200-day. The Ladder stepped out at Tuesday's open and sits at 0% exposure. QQQ trades 13.9% below its high; the -15% line, the third warning, sits near 648.4.
- Trend Safety Switch: 0%, with the trend line around 707.7.
- Market Fear Meter: fear rank near 99, very high, but no new fear-spike signal at this close.
The re-entry rules are mechanical. VIX closing under ~19.99 or QQQ closing above ~682.9 knocks one warning off and brings the Ladder back in at the next open. A close under ~648.4 triggers the third warning. A close above ~707.7 flips the Trend Safety Switch back up.
SPY warrants its own watch. It carries 1 of 3 warnings (VIX only) and closed Tuesday a hair above its own 200-day — 732.44 versus roughly 732.3. If SPY closes under ~732.6 while VIX holds above ~19.99, that's a second warning, and the SPY Ladder steps out at Thursday's open.
The caveats matter here
The author flags real limits: one ticker, daily closes, dividend-adjusted history. Unadjusted data gives 27 cases with a similar picture — median 5 sessions below and the same three long drawdowns. A 35-case sample is small, the analysis excludes costs and taxes, and past cases guarantee nothing about this one. It's not advice.
The bottom line for anyone managing Nasdaq exposure: Wednesday's close is the decision point, not Nvidia's print. VIX below ~20 or QQQ above ~683 de-escalates; a close under ~648 puts the full three-warning stack on and confirms this break is different from most of the last 35.
Source: tradingview.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,352 articles