QQQ Scorecard: Trend Tool Cut Risk Early, Fast Signals Paid Whipsaw Cost
QQQ closed Friday at 679.89, 10.5% off its October 6 high. One trader's mechanical rules cut risk early, then paid whipsaw costs on re-entry in the V-shaped dip.
By Amara Osei
4 min read

What's News
- QQQ closed Friday at 679.89, 10.5% below its October 6 closing high of 759.66.
- A Trend Safety Switch cut exposure from 100% to 30% on October 14 at 728.95; QQQ fell another 6.7% after.
- A Risk-Off Ladder exit at the November 6 open (658.35) and re-entry at the November 11 open (687.28) cost 4.4% in whipsaw.
- SPY's Risk-Off Ladder never left 100% exposure, maxing at 1 of 3 warnings even on the November 5 low close of 733.00.
- Nvidia reports Tuesday after the close; a VIX close above ~19.92 with QQQ under ~682 would drop the Ladder to 0%.
QQQ closed Friday at 679.89, 10.5% below its October 6 closing high of 759.66. TheSimplePortfolio, a TradingView author who posted every mechanical signal from a set of free risk tools in real time, has now published the full scorecard of what worked and what didn't through the sell-off. The verdict: the slow trend tool did its job. The fast tools paid for it.
What got right — and what missed?
The Trend Safety Switch fired first. On October 14, the trend turned down and the rule cut exposure from 100% to 30% at 728.95, when QQQ was already 4.0% off its top. The fund has fallen another 6.7% since. "Right, but late by 4%," the author wrote.
The fast signals didn't fare as well:
- Market Fear Meter, October 21 and October 27: two "fear fading" signals at 725.20 and 721.25. Both failed. Fear returned within days, and QQQ now sits 6.2% and 5.7% below those levels.
- Risk-Off Ladder, November 5: 3 of 3 warnings triggered, exiting at the November 6 open of 658.35. Most of the damage came on November 5 itself, a -5.3% open-to-close move, so the rule stepped aside after the hit, not before it. Warnings fell back to 2 of 3, then 1 of 3 on November 10, and the rule re-entered at the November 11 open of 687.28 — 4.4% higher than where it sold. "Wrong this round," the author said. "That's the cost of a 2-alarm rule in a fast V-shaped dip."
- Trend Safety Switch, November 5: the final 30% went to 0% at 647.05. QQQ is 5.1% higher now. "Wrong so far on that last 30%." A November 9 fear-fading signal at 679.35 remains open.
How did SPY's rules behave?
SPY produced a cleaner result. The Trend Safety Switch cut from 100% to 30% on October 30 at 755.72; SPY closed Friday at 754.37, so that call is flat so far. The Risk-Off Ladder never left 100% exposure. It registered at most 1 of 3 warnings, even on the November 5 low close of 733.00, which was 5.9% off the top. "Right: SPY's dip stayed a dip," the author noted.
The author's own summary is blunt: the slow trend tool cut before most of the drop, and the fast tools paid whipsaw costs. "That's the trade-off I chose on purpose," they wrote. "Small, frequent costs, in exchange for not sitting through a 2000, 2008 or 2022. One month doesn't prove anything either way."
Where do the signals stand after Friday's close?
QQQ sits 0.3% under its 200-day moving average of roughly 682, keeping that warning on. The VIX at 19.30 remains below its warning line of about 19.92. The -15% line sits near 648. That combination counts as 1 of 3, so the Ladder holds 100% exposure, while the Trend Safety Switch stands at 0% with its trend line at about 710 — 4.4% above the price.
SPY is 3.1% above its 200-day of roughly 732, at 0 of 3 warnings, with the Ladder at 100%. Its Trend Safety Switch stays at 30% until a close above about 773, which is 2.5% above Friday's price.
What could flip the signals this week?
Nvidia reports Tuesday after the close, and the author lists four mechanical triggers:
- VIX closes above about 19.92 while QQQ stays under about 682: 2 of 3, and the Ladder goes to 0%.
- QQQ closes back above about 682: the 200-day warning turns off.
- QQQ closes above about 710: the Trend Safety Switch turns back up.
- SPY closes above about 773: its switch returns to 100%.
The author promises to post a note when any of these fire.
The stated limits are candid: one month, two tickers, daily closes, and no taxes or transaction costs. "Signals are mechanical and can and do miss," the author wrote. "Not advice, just what the rules did." For anyone weighing systematic risk rules against buy-and-hold, the month offers a live data point: trend filters captured most of the drawdown, but re-entry timing in a V-shaped dip cost real basis points.
Source: tradingview.com
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,136 articles